DIGITISER
  • MAIN PAGE
  • Features
  • Videos
  • Game Reviews
  • FAQ

REVIEW: GHOST OF TSUSHIMA (PS4)

27/7/2020

26 Comments

 
Picture
Ghost of Tsushima is the PS4's last big honk, its final big platform exclusive, discharging into our laps a month or so after the penultimate big platform exclusive, The Last of Us Part 2.

To say I enjoyed TLoU2 would be an understatement. It would also be inaccurate. I mean, it's the most miserable video game ever made. I don't think anybody could actually enjoy that amount of relentless anguish and anxiety. It was like being strapped into a gnarly chair, with your eyes forced open by a couple of uncomfortable metal hooks, while Twitter scrolls in front of you on a big screen. 

Also: the room is full of hungry rats. And you're not wearing shoes or trousers. 

It probably didn't help that I binged it in three days, by the end of which I emerged bow-legged from its unrelenting emotional pounding. That isn't a criticism; it just shows you how effective The Last of Us 2 was at making me feel stuff. In my view, there's no doubt it's one of the greatest video games ever made, its lustre dimmed only by the radicalism of bigots.  

While I accept it may have driven its development team to near collapse, it doesn't so much raise the bar for the right way to achieve video game storytelling and characterisation as strap it to a rocket it and fire it into the moon. 

Tsushima, therefore, had a tough act to follow. Regardless, there's no bar-raising here; they keep it firmly on the ground, surrounded by all the predictable comforts we've grown accustomed to. For a game so full of horses, it is perhaps understandable that it did so little to scare them.  

Whereas TLoU2 had a story that could never be easily summarised in a single sentence, Tsushima can be encapsulated thus: a samurai man does some things, because the Mongols have invaded the pretty island where he lives. 

Wait. Two sentences: sometimes he gets a new hat!

And you sometimes see his bare bum. 

Three sentences, then. 
Picture
A MAN WHO DOES THINGS
As you'd want from a game in which you play a samurai man doing some things, the combat in Ghost of Tshushima is its strongest element.

Though it starts out pretty basic, as you progress your character gains abilities that border the supernatural, acquiring 'stances' that you can switch between mid-battle, and which give you an advantage over certain enemy types. Pretty swiftly, your character reaches a point where he's virtually indestructible. I think I probably died three, maybe four, times throughout the entire game. Who needs challenge when you've got a really big map?

Naturally, there are assorted weapon types, which won't raise too many eyebrows; aside from swords and daggers, you get bows, smoke bombs, and grenade-like things. Including one of my personal video game bugbears; sticky bombs. 

Now, let's get this clear; sticky bombs were a form of demolition ordinance developed during WW2. They didn't exist before that point. Indeed, they weren't even widely distributed during the war, as they were considered unreliable; something which the classic BBC sitcom Dad's Army made a virtue of in that episode where Lance Corporal Jones gets one stuck to a dustbin lid he's holding.

I think most of us first heard of the sticky bomb in Saving Private Ryan, when Tom Hanks' character improvises some during the climactic battle scene. Almost immediately, they became as ubiquitous in video games as health packs. In short: they certainly didn't exist in feudal Japan, and they certainly have never been thrown at enemies mid-melee. 

But... Ghost of Tsushima, for all the reaching it does to provide an experience that somehow transcends video games, can't escape what it is. If video games were a sticky bomb, it's stuck to Ghost of Tsushima's face, and no amount of running around in circles, shrieking out haikus, can shift it. I mean, the inclusion of fast travel isn't exactly breaking the mould.
Picture
DIFFERENT STROKES?
While it tries so hard to be different, Ghost of Tsushima's structure is as predictable as modern games get. For all its developers claim that they eschewed the worst tropes of open world design, all they've really done is disguise them slightly. 

​The map unfurls gradually, revealing story missions, side missions, and various secondary objectives that allow you to upgrade your character. Some of these upgrades are cosmetic - complete this mission, and you can get some funky red trousers - while others will reward you with new weaponry, or skill points. There are enemy bases to liberate, and a sprinkling of light detective work, but rarely does it stretch beyond the usual go-here/kill-these-people formula that we're all accustomed to.

What it tries to do to set it apart from all the other open world map-mopping out there is its wholesale embracing of 13th Century Japan. How much of it is accurate, and how much of it is trying to evoke what we imagine it to have been like, I cannot say. But expect plenty of shrines, healing hot springs, petting of foxes, haikus, and a whole lot of talk about honour. Which swiftly gets dropped once the main character realises that some objectives can only be completed using stealth. 

Somewhere in there, it's trying to connect your character to nature; instead of a GTA-style GPS, you summon gusts of wind to direct you to your mission waypoint. This, like much in the game, is just window dressing; it's a re-skin of game mechanics we've seen countless times before.  

It's a shame, because one of the most interesting elements of Tsushima early on is how it seemed to be going against gaming's tedency towards stealth missions, by having your character stride into enemy bases, and issuing a challenge. This remains an element throughout - providing you've not been seen, you can call out a group of enemies, which results in a sort of one-on-one, face-off mini game, where you need to time the unsheathing of your katana. Unfortunately, some missions demand you do the stealth thing, lest Mongol captors start slaughtering the prisoners you're trying to rescue. 

More often than not, it's just easier and quicker to burst into an enemy camp and start slaughtering Mongols, rather than faff around distracting them with wind chimes and firecrackers. 

DISCREPANCY
This discrepancy is what I found most frustrating about Tsushima; how it sort of wants to be something other, embracing a slower pace, but snaps back to predictable gaming tropes before it ever gets a chance to really explore territory that is legitimately different and new. As if they went so far down a certain path, and then bottled it. They even seem to have tried to balance out the measured rhythms elsewhere, by making your character's movements almost superhumanly fast. 

Unlike, say, Far Cry, when you really feel it when you pick flowers or strip bamboo, or skin a dog, here it happens instantly. There's none of Red Dead's weighty grounding in reality, which allows the player to really embed themselves in that world; your character glides through Tsushima like Pac-Man. It hurries along, until you smash face-first into one of its many cutscenes. 

This weird discrepancy, this mix of good and bad, extends to the visuals too. Given all the pre-release hype about what a beautiful game it is, I found myself disappointed by the graphics early on. They seemed to be trying too hard to look lush, but often the sparse, clean, scenery felt painfully last-gen, and same-y. Once it gets into the second act, though, things really picked up, and I started to see what everyone was talking about; it is a beautiful game, no question. Plus, its setting gives it a unique atmosphere. Yes, we're back in forests and climbing up mountains, but often those are bamboo forests, and the mountains look like ukiyo-e paintings.

What continued to be an issue for me was the animation; once characters are in motion it looks great. Riding across a field of flowers is never less than gorgeous, but the transition from one animation state to another can be jarring and clunky. NPCs all run the same, they turn like robots, and the issue is compounded by the way every character pretty much has the same move cycle.

The cut-scenes - of which I'll say more shortly - veered between spot-on Kurosawa pastiches (you can even play the game in black and white, for added authenticity), and bland talking heads. 

For me, though, where Tsushima almost crumbles entirely, is its narrative. God, it's boring.
Picture
ANCIENT JAPAN
The way Ghost of Tsushima tells its story feels very old-fashioned. And not even old-fashioned in a good way, like harkening back to some halcyon period. More like it's harkening back to stuff that we've been growing tired of for some time. It's not so much yearning for Spangles, as sighing because Michael McIntyre's on the telly again. 

Released in the wake of The Last of Us Part 2, Tsushima's bland, petri dish-deep, characters, stand out as little more than ciphers. Nobody feels real, nobody has the sort of human concerns most of us can relate to.

I think - but can't be sure - that they were trying to tell a story about stories, legends... but that's less interesting than exploring the reality behind those legend. Your main character, Jin Sakai, is an empty vessel into whom we can pour our fantasy of becoming a legendary samurai. Or at least, that's the intention, I think. Aren't we all a bit more clued-up these days? We know our heroes, our legends, are as flawed as the rest of us.

If we'd been afford the opportunity of playing as the real Jin Sakai, the man behind the myth, rather than the myth itself - somebody trying to live up to his legend - I might've felt it easier to relate and engage with the game's narrative. Regrettably, here's no attempt to humanise this stoic, revenge-driven, man. He has all the layers of a single sheet of A4. 

I mean, none of this would be a problem were Tsushima able to accept what it is; an action video game. We never needed Q*Bert's inner struggle. We accepted Mario's simplistic goals. But that's because those games knew what they were, and left us to create our own adventures.

Unfortunately, in Tsushima, the cut-scenes are piled on thick, and you can't skip them. They force you to watch the story rather than interact with it. Worse still, most of the non-interactive moments are also completely unnecessary.

Example: you'll travel to a mission start point to speak to a character. You'll get an interminably dull cut-scene, that lasts a good 20 seconds too long, and then he'll ask you to follow him. Good. Back into the game. Except: you and he walk somewhere 10 feet away, and you get another cut-scene that drags on. Then some more walking. Then another cut-scene. Walking. New character. Cut-scene. Walking. Now go somewhere else; get on horse. Oh, you've bumped into a group of Mongols holding a prisoner. Rescue prisoner by slaughtering Mongols. Talk to prisoner. New cut-scene. 

Given the sheer number of them, I'd wager that 75% of the cut-scenes in Tsushima are extraneous. They're not even interesting. They don't reveal anything about character; it's usually about the mission. It's just bad writing, and worse storytelling. They slow the pace to a crawl. That'd be fine, but as I said before... they seem to have then overcompensated with Jin's spritely movements. It actually felt more like they're always hurrying you towards the next cut-scene, so they can show off their watery screenwriting skills. 
Picture
BE INTERESTING
If games are to force a story upon us, that story needs to engage us. We need characters we care about.

Arguably, The Last of Us 2 might go too far in the other direction - piling on backstory upon backstory, heaping misery upon its protagonists (and antagonists) - but at least I cared about all of it. For all its side missions, Tsushima is a far more linear experience, purely for its A-B character journey. There's a bit of a late-stage twist, but it doesn't really feel earned. Despite spending hours exploring a vast, Japanese, island, I didn't feel like I'd been on any sort of journey.

​I've always argued that if you're going to tell a story in a video game, make sure it's a story that can only be told in a video game. Some of my favourite moments in The Last of Us 2 are where characters are simply talking, but... in those moments I've often got control over a character. I'm interacting with the world. I'm invested in who they are. I know no moment will be wasted. It treats cut-scenes as story beats, not mission briefings. Characters are motivated by deeper concerns, driven by emotion, not externally-imposed game rules. 

Because Ghost of Tsushima fails to do any of this, because it can't rationalise its need to be a video game, with its creators' desire to tell a story, it feels achingly out of step. It might be the last big PS4 exclusive of this generation, but it already feels like it belongs in the past.

​Still, at least you get to see his bare bum.

​SCORE: 1274 out of 2020
26 Comments
RaptorHammer7 (Twitch name) link
27/7/2020 10:55:10 am

I’ve not played TLoU yet, but I really liked the bits in God of War (PS4) where they chat on the boat, the way that game tells the story with very few cut scenes was refreshing. Now games can all do amazing graphics, I hope the way the stories are told gets more focus, shame it doesn’t seem to be the case here.

Reply
Dave Trotter
27/7/2020 11:00:28 am

I'll probs leave it until it shows up on PS+ then. I wasn't wholly interested in the first place and this review has cemented my desires to not part with any of my hard earned.

Reply
Nikki
27/7/2020 11:11:25 am

what would the score have been if you didn't see his bum?

Reply
Grembot
27/7/2020 11:24:08 am

I’m really enjoying it so far. I’m finding it enjoyably videogame-y - which perhaps I needed following TLOU2. I don’t tend to play open world games so I’m not fatigued by the genre and I’ve been playing with Japanese voice acting which adds some overblown melodrama.

Actually it’s so game-y that I’ve got a real desire for some anachronistic DLC where you get cyber samurai armour or something.

Reply
Reversible Sedgewick
27/7/2020 01:39:35 pm

"the opportunity of playing as the real Jin Sakai, the man behind the myth, rather than the myth itself - somebody trying to live up to his legend"

That sounds like the start of series 2 of Heroes, before the writers' strike made the pacing all weird and the show fell to bits.

There used to be a cafe in Oxford called Heroes and someone would always graffiti a long line downwards from the left side of the "o".

I think I've gone off-topic.

Reply
Seam
27/7/2020 02:20:28 pm

I’m really enjoying it. All of the points raised in the review are valid but I still find it enjoyable to play. I’m not too fussed about the cut scenes other than I don’t know why they need to fade in & out. It would be better if they just happened.
After playing TLOU2 and being mentally and emotionally exhausted, Ghost of Tsushima came as welcome enjoyable relief.
I love open world games anyway and Ghost hits enough of the good points I enjoy to keep me coming back. I got excited when I was able to get a new black straw hat, which replaced a red one I was equally excited to get. I could spend all day just taking pictures in the photo mode.
Just starting Act 2 now so still got quite a bit of game ahead of me.

Reply
Roddy O'Glork
27/7/2020 03:37:24 pm

Don't understand why you're getting so much grief in the comments section

Reply
Mr Biffo
27/7/2020 03:51:04 pm

We have a troll, that's all.

Reply
lilock3
27/7/2020 04:29:38 pm

Sounds about on par with what I was expecting. I'm a sucker for a good map-mopper though, so may pick this up in a couple of years when it's heavily discounted.

Reply
Christian Dabnor link
27/7/2020 05:44:48 pm

I loved The Last of Us 2, especially the second play through (I'd slight concerns about character arcs, but spoilers). It had all the emotional weight David Cage claimed his games had (I got properly riled at times and there's a character that other people might not be too bothered about, but I really hate them after the second play). I used the word polish about it before, and it is a highly polished product, up there with the likes of Red Dead Redemption 2 and, well, probably not much else. GTA V maybe. Ghost of Tsushima doesn't have that polish. I think once in TLOU2 I got stuck on scenery and fell through the world once. In GoT over the past couple of days I've got stuck in scenery several times. Plus the horse tails are terrible and that bugs me much more than it should. However, I am enjoying it. A lot. I agree with your criticisms, but my enjoyment is not diminished by it. I used to like the Assassin's Creed games (although not played any in a while, and never will again because Ubisoft), so this is very familiar and comfortable ground for me. Perhaps that's it. Perhaps it's the familiarity that makes me happy.

Reply
Nick
27/7/2020 06:04:30 pm

A bum you say? Sold!

Reply
Penyrolewen
28/7/2020 08:25:01 pm

Haven’t played this or TLOU2 but great to see you here again Biffo! Sorry the troll is still about (although I can’t see any comments so guessing you’re removing them) but just so pleased to see a new article!

Reply
King of Sass
28/7/2020 11:06:01 pm

I am very happy to see a new article on the site! Funnily enough I recall you stating a dislike for both stealth and cut-scenes back in the Teletext days so your tastes in that regard are certainly consistent. I'd be happy with an early-90s amount myself. Quick intro, maybe an ending, and on some occasions a bit of text and a picture between sections of the game. Brevity being the key to storytelling and all that.

Reply
Adam
29/7/2020 02:22:40 am

Yay! Digi2000 lives again!

Reply
Jim
29/7/2020 11:45:02 pm

It's superb 2 av u back, g8 review biffster 2000

Reply
Random Reviewer
31/7/2020 09:24:14 pm

What unsettles me about the discussion around TLO2 and GoT is the feeling that liking/disliking either game means we are picking a side in a larger culture war. I don't really feel like playing either. TLoU2 looks like a misery generator that uses crude parlour tricks to goad a response out of the player. GoT looks quite formulaic, and it reminds me of the way Siphon Filter was ludicrously overhyped as the last hurrah of the PS1. But then again I haven't played either, so I might be talking total cack.

Reply
King of Sass
3/8/2020 11:19:11 am

Is that the thing about TLOU2 trying to make you feel bad about shooting a dog? I heard about that and I think I might not be the intended audience. I don't think I could possibly be upset about killing a video game dog, and even if I could, then the game would make me upset. That's not what I want out of a video game. I didn't play Pac-Man at the arcade so I could have a good cry!

Reply
Random Reviewer
4/8/2020 03:12:04 am

I think the dog thing is a small example of TLoU2's emotional sleight of hand. From the playthroughs I've seen, dogs appear to be a particularly difficult enemy. The game trains you to view them as a pain in the arse. Then it throws a scene at you where the only option to progress is to kill a dog. There is no alternative offered.

Then it reveals that dog was the best buddy of the antagonist, a person who has done horrific things to the established characters. The game switches control to the antagonist and actually has you play fetch with it. I guess the intent would be to show how an animal that was a viscous obstacle for Ellie could be a friend to someone else, dualism and all that. But it's done in such a thumpingly obvious way.

Even if you're a dog lover, it's hard to have any empathy at that point, since the game has already thrown them at you as a difficult enemy. Attempts to humanise the antagonist fall flat as well, especially when weighing up the new information against what we know they've done. It's too little, too late.

The actual gameplay mechanics look fun, but the amount of emotional manipulation in the story make it feel like a snuff movie produced by Disney.

Balaska
1/8/2020 08:59:29 am

"Whereas TLoU2 had a story that could never be easily summarised in a single sentence, Tsushima can be encapsulated thus: a samurai man does some things, because the Mongols have invaded the pretty island where he lives.

Wait. Two sentences: sometimes he gets a new hat!

And you sometimes see his bare bum.

Three sentences, then. "

Sold, sold and SOLD

Reply
Timmypoos
8/8/2020 10:33:50 pm

This review has just about convinced me to give TLOU2 a go. I was hoping ghost would be something akin to an open world Sekiro, not Farcry (historical) Japan.

Reply
BobMonkeypimp
8/8/2020 11:05:21 pm

I despised TLOU 1. I just hated everything about it, gameplay was boring & if the story was good, I never got to find out because I was too bored after an hours play. I'm not disrespecting the majority who did enjoy it, it just wasn't for me.

Ghost of Tsushima, well I'm enjoying that very much. It actually feels like a game & plays like a game. I only got it yesterday so I'm not too far in but already I'm happy with my purchase.

Good to see you back Biffo.

Reply
Drunkndandy
10/8/2020 08:58:40 pm

In my mind its up against shadows die twice, and it seemz to be the weaker ninja/samurai game

Reply
BobMonkeypimp
11/8/2020 09:25:37 pm

I've heard Shadows Die Twice is a difficult game. When I play as a samurai I want to feel like a Japanese tough guy & not get my ass handed to me. :)

Truthfully though, I don't mind difficult games so is SDT worth buying?

Reply
King of Sass
15/8/2020 06:10:54 pm

I borrowed Sekiro from a friend as I had enjoyed Bloodborne but I didn't like it as much. To me, it felt hard in an annoying way where I always felt like I was just dying over and over then eventually getting past bits by sheer luck each time.

Pauly_C
17/8/2020 02:59:20 pm

I bloody loved this game.

Reply
Martin "Biscuits and tea" Williams
5/3/2021 08:08:02 am

Absolutely loved this review, such an engaging read, and streets ahead of even the high quality gaming publications. Still crying laughing at the point about Q-bert's inner struggle 😂

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    This section will not be visible in live published website. Below are your current settings:


    Current Number Of Columns are = 2

    Expand Posts Area =

    Gap/Space Between Posts = 12px

    Blog Post Style = card

    Use of custom card colors instead of default colors = 1

    Blog Post Card Background Color = current color

    Blog Post Card Shadow Color = current color

    Blog Post Card Border Color = current color

    Publish the website and visit your blog page to see the results

    Picture
    Support Me on Ko-fi
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    RSS Feed Widget
    Picture

    Picture
    Tweets by @mrbiffo
    Picture
    Follow us on The Facebook

    Picture

    Archives

    December 2022
    May 2022
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    November 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014


    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • MAIN PAGE
  • Features
  • Videos
  • Game Reviews
  • FAQ